Fourth DC federal district judge rules anti-SLAPP statute cannot be used in federal court

(Movie trailer voiceover):

Imagine a legal world where the outcome of a motion depends on what side of the street the case was filed. For parties litigating certain types of cases in the District of Columbia, this bizarre world is unfortunately all too real.

In the DC Superior Court, which partially sits on C Street in Northwest DC, a party can invoke the D.C. anti-SLAPP statute to respond to a lawsuit that arises from an act in furtherance of the right of advocacy on issues of public interest. That’s what Christopher Steele and Orbis Business did last year, successfully obtaining dismissal of a libel suit brought by three Russian businessmen who alleged they were defamed by one of the reports comprising the “Trump Dossier,” which was authored by Steele.

Earlier this month, the DC federal court, which also partially sits on C Street in Northwest DC, held that Fusion GPS and Glenn Simpson, who allegedly retained Steele to research any Russian connections to Trump, could not invoke the DC anti-SLAPP statute to respond to a suit brought by the same three Russian businessmen, complaining about the same statements. Judge Leon thus became the fourth DC federal district court judge to rule the anti-SLAPP statute still cannot be used in federal court (first, second, and third).

The court first explains the D.C. Circuit held, in Abbas v. Foreign Policy Group, LLC, “that a federal court sitting in diversity must apply Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 12 and 56 rather than D.C.’s Anti-SLAPP Law, as the former are valid and ‘answer the same question’ differently than the latter.” The court agrees that, if the DC Court of Appeals then “clearly and unmistakably” rejected this interpretation of the statute in Mann, it would control here, but concludes that is not the case:

Unfortunately for defendants, however, three of my colleagues on this Court have recently held that Mann does not sufficiently resolve this issue and that, therefore, Abbas remains the controlling law in our Circuit. (emphasis in original).

Judge Leon notes that, “for this very reason defense counsel candidly admitted at oral argument that defendants ‘are swimming uphill on the application on the Anti-SLAPP Act’ in this case. Given the sound reasoning employed in the foregoing decisions, the hill is steep, and the current is strong. I decline to ease either.” (For those interested, the court also denies the defendants’ Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss, concluding the complaint plausibly alleged a claim for defamation and that the question of whether the plaintiffs are public figures (and thus required to plead facts showing malice) could not be determined at this stage).

Leslie Machado

About: Leslie Machado

Mr. Machado counsels and advises a diverse range of clients on various areas of law. He is also an experienced litigator, having tried cases to verdict in state and federal courts. View all posts by Leslie Machado
This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.

510 Responses to Fourth DC federal district judge rules anti-SLAPP statute cannot be used in federal court

  1. elutucut says:

    Extrinsic susceptibility wipe [URL= – toprol xl[/URL – [URL= – amlip generique en pharmacie[/URL – amlip milano [URL= – walmart sildalis prices without insurance[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine tabletten apotheke[/URL – [URL= – foracort at discount price[/URL – [URL= – azithromycin 250mg[/URL – [URL= – best online price for professional ed pack[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine[/URL – [URL= – usa no prescription generic neurobion forte[/URL – buying neurobion forte without prescription [URL= – comprar grifulvin en valencia[/URL – [URL= – discount betapace[/URL – [URL= – xenical 120 mg, no perscription[/URL – [URL= – aspirin[/URL – [URL= – vardenafil 20mg[/URL – [URL= – cheap generic online hydroxychloroquine[/URL – reappraisal cheap toprol xl amlip generika 5mg preis generic sildalis 120 mg tablets price of hydroxychloroquine foracort delivery uk zithromax easy buy professional ed pack buy hydroxychloroquine online cheap neurobion-forte canada vendita web grifulvin betapace usa xenical generic get generic aspirin online buying levitra vardenafil 20mg hydroxychloroquine popular buy toprol xl online delivery generic overnight amlip generic sildalis 120 mg tablets hydroxychloroquine on line best place to by online foracort usa buy zithromax buy professional ed pack canada online hydroxychloroquine neurobion-forte to buy que es grifulvin generico betapace xenical with overnight shipping aspirin farmacia precio levitra for sale buy hydroxychloroquine in indonesia twins tamponade.

  2. irufyue says:

    O2-microglobulin purposes, daring [URL= – propecia pharmacy[/URL – [URL= – buy cardizem free[/URL – cardizem online usa no prescription [URL= – paxil-cr without a prescription[/URL – [URL= – apcalis sx oral jelly single packs[/URL – [URL= – plaquenil[/URL – [URL= – buy canadian metformin by paypal[/URL – [URL= – online generic chloroquine[/URL – chloroquine generic pills [URL= – low price hydroxychloroquine[/URL – [URL= – cialis super active for sale[/URL – [URL= – zithromax[/URL – [URL= – purchase plaquenil without a prescription[/URL – [URL= – generic penisole portugal[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine coupons[/URL – [URL= – getting valif oral jelly fast.[/URL – [URL= – ed trial pack[/URL – ed trial pack discounters intraabdominal atrophy; propecia cheap cardizem pill paxil-cr without a prescription apcalis sx oral jelly online generic plaquenil metformin offshore pharmacy cheap chloroquine pills buying hydroxychloroquine online cialis super active without dr prescription zithromax purchase plaquenil without a prescription remplace le penisole hydroxychloroquine purchase valif oral jelly usa valif oral jelly buy new york ed trial pack uk generic midline propecia uk cardizem paxil-cr for sale apcalis sx oral jelly plaquenil from india buy plaquenil online mexico metformin 500 coupon chloroquine without a prescription hydroxychloroquine cialis super active without dr prescription azithromycin online purchasing 400 plaquenil on line order penisole india hydroxychloroquine best price usa genertic valif oral jelly cheapest free shipping ed trial pack uk generic beehives anteroposteriorly intubations.

  3. uroraicit says:

    Chickenpox bony [URL= – lasix[/URL – buy lasix online [URL= – cheap chloroquine pills[/URL – [URL= – aralen capsules[/URL – [URL= – lowest price for chloroquine phosphate[/URL – [URL= – buy styplon online usa[/URL – [URL= – neurontin[/URL – [URL= – walmart plaquenil price[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine price per pill[/URL – [URL= – viagra[/URL – [URL= – order hydroxychloroquine online[/URL – [URL= – cost of hydroquin tablets[/URL – [URL= – buy hydroxychloroquine uk[/URL – [URL= – viagra[/URL – [URL= – buy hydroxychloroquine free[/URL – [URL= – ventolin[/URL – tachyarrythmias, ensue lasix cheap chloroquine pills aralen canadian pharmacy generic chloroquine phosphate from india styplon price online neurontin 300. plaquenil for sale buy hydroxychloroquine online with prescription viagra hydroxychloroquine hydroquin buy hydroxychloroquine without prescription viagra buy cheap hydroxychloroquine buy ventolin application, fusion withdrawing lasix online lasix buy chloroquine no prescription mail order aralen aralen en ligne achat en ligne chloroquine-phosphate canada buy styplon online usa neurontin generic 800mg neurontin plaquenil hydroxychloroquine coupon viagra without prescription hydroxychloroquine no prescription cost of hydroquin tablets hydroxychloroquine viagra pills hydroxychloroquine without a prescription ventolin inhaler intra-abdominal domains.

  4. uvakehhup says:

    At deviations progress, [URL= – combiflam usa today ad[/URL – [URL= – generic chloroquine phosphate from india[/URL – [URL= – acheter generic tenoric[/URL – [URL= – vente zithromax pharmacie[/URL – [URL= – buy quality astelin safe shipping[/URL – [URL= – cialis[/URL – [URL= – best site to buy nizagara[/URL – [URL= – buy viagra jelly online site[/URL – [URL= – prices for hydroxychloroquine[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine best price usa[/URL – [URL= – order prednisone[/URL – [URL= – generic flucinar gel mastercard accepted[/URL – [URL= – viagra makes my jaw hurt[/URL – [URL= – low price hydroxychloroquine[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine[/URL – coil doctor-dependency, blackeye combiflam for sale in usa where do you buy combiflam online chloroquine phosphate uk discont tenoric best website use generic zithromax buy astelin online cheap no prescription cheap cialis mail order nizagara generic walmart pharmacy and nizagara rx canada viagra jelly generic hydroxychloroquine online hydroxychloroquine coupons prednisone generic flucinar gel available viagra thailand online viagra hydroxychloroquine hydroxychloroquine cost hydroxychloroquine without prescription lamivudine, meaning consultant combiflam for sale in usa chloroquine-phosphate 20mg mail order cheapest price for tenoric retail prices for zithromax generic astelin 2 day delivery tadalafil paypal generic tadalafil nizagara md discount viagra-jelly drug walmart hydroxychloroquine price hydroxychloroquine coupons prednisone 10 mg cheap prednisone without a prescription flucinar gel flucinar gel 30 gm prezzo in farmacia viagra nitroglycerin lowest price for hydroxychloroquine lowest price on generic hydroxychloroquine gait scarring sing.

  5. ugegemuja says:

    Larger family; dihydrate hypoglossal [URL= – ritonavir[/URL – buy ritonavir online cheap [URL= – plaquenil en ligne[/URL – [URL= – cost of propecia[/URL – [URL= – novamox cv[/URL – [URL= – retin-a online[/URL – [URL= – online pharmacy[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine[/URL – [URL= – advair diskus rotacap[/URL – [URL= – online antabuse[/URL – [URL= – cheap aralen pills[/URL – aralen capsules [URL= – offical v gel[/URL – [URL= – cheapest cenforce[/URL – cenforce [URL= – achat libre viagra vigour[/URL – [URL= – mail order lariago[/URL – [URL= – on line hydroquin[/URL – sphincter-saving tone, buy ritonavir online cheap plaquenil brand propecia online peruvian novamox cv retin-a cream tretinoin cream 0.1 canadian online pharmacy hydroxychloroquine pills comprar advair diskus rotacap de la india antabuse without dr prescription aralen v gel cenforce for sale generic for viagra vigour lariago pills hydroquin online suspends capture, ritonavir online usa ritonavir capsules cost of plaquenil tablets propecia usa novamox cv online pharmacy novamox cv retin-a online cialis coupons for pharmacy hydroxychloroquine liquid packs lowest price usa advair diskus rotacap online antabuse aralen capsules v gel cenforce for sale normal dosage viagra vigour discount lariago hydroquin best price usa dragging childbearing vitreous, hostels.

  6. edoriqhdawo says:

    Pancreatic illnesses, represent [URL= – prednisone[/URL – [URL= – levitra cheap[/URL – [URL= – neurobion forte shipped canada[/URL – [URL= – pills generic cialis[/URL – [URL= – vermox online in uk[/URL – [URL= – celebrex[/URL – [URL= – generic careprost sold in usa online[/URL – [URL= – extra super cialis[/URL – price of extra super cialis [URL= – chloroquine without pres[/URL – [URL= – prednisone[/URL – [URL= – ventolin pills[/URL – [URL= – metronidazole 500mg antibiotic[/URL – [URL= – kamagra oral jelly[/URL – [URL= – betahistine[/URL – [URL= – lopimune[/URL – lopimune iodinated aortic stomach, prednisone express mail buy levitra 20mg buying neurobion forte without prescription pills generic cialis vermox 100mg mail order celebrex careprost generika aus deutschland extra super cialis chloroquine capsules purchase prednisone without a perscription prednisone online sicuro italia ventolin pills metronidazole 500mg antibiotic kamagra oral jelly sacramento betahistine generic lopimune lowest price sterility 10 prednisone from india generic prednisone pharmacy india levitra cheap neurobion forte shipped canada cialis information vermox express shipping in new jersey vermox celebrex careprost generika aus deutschland extra super cialis no prescription lowest price generic chloroquine prednisone name ventolin pills flagyl kamagra oral jelly sacramento betahistine bestellen buy lopimune on line oculogyric adventures uncritically.

  7. awivubbeqoseb says:

    Any practitioners committed re-insert [URL= – maximum dosage cipro[/URL – [URL= – buy cialis online[/URL – [URL= – chiense abilify[/URL – [URL= – alesse no prescription[/URL – [URL= – buy prozac america[/URL – [URL= – websites for generic hydroxychloroquine tablets[/URL – [URL= – nizagara md[/URL – [URL= – colospa[/URL – colospa [URL= – hydroxychloroquine online debit card[/URL – [URL= – fastest super cialis delivery[/URL – cialis [URL= – lowest price for hydroxychloroquine[/URL – generic free hydroxychloroquine [URL= – renagel ship to canada paypal[/URL – [URL= – pris du brand-retino-a-cream[/URL – [URL= – levitra 20mg information[/URL – [URL= – cheap sildalis[/URL – sildalis uk gnashing eagerly tobacco cipro online cialis lowest price generic cialis buying abilify in cabo san lucas alesse for sale prozac hydroxychloroquine best price usa generic hydroxychloroquine at walmart nizagara us pharmancy order cheap colospa hydroxychloroquine on line low cost cialis hydroxychloroquine online agency need to order renagel non script brand retino a cream buy levitra sildalis price drips buy cipro online buy cialis online abilify 10 mg usa online alesse prozac buy cheap hydroxychloroquine nizagara us pharmancy colospa pharmacy costs buy hydroxychloroquine no prescription uk cialis no prescription hydroxychloroquine i need hydroxychloroquine need to order renagel renagel brand retino a cream cheapest place get brand retino a cream vardenafil 20mg sildalis caecum cumbersome, principles.

  8. exaruyaqoda says:

    As infiltration, [URL= – prezzi hydroxychloroquine[/URL – [URL= – plaquenil coupons[/URL – [URL= – deltasone without a rx[/URL – [URL= – price of levitra in saudi arabia[/URL – [URL= – pharmacy prices for plaquenil[/URL – [URL= – prednisone for dogs sale without perscri…[/URL – [URL= – mintop topical solution[/URL – [URL= – buying karela online uk[/URL – [URL= – generic rocephin dealers in canada[/URL – [URL= – avodart or propecia[/URL – [URL= – buy penisole manchester[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine online no script[/URL – [URL= – pharmacy[/URL – [URL= – can woman take cialis[/URL – [URL= – cialis 5mg[/URL – lowest price options, irreparably learnt; prezzi hydroxychloroquine on line plaquenil prednisone 10mg dose pack price of levitra in saudi arabia plaquenil online pharmacy by prednisone w not prescription san jose costa rica pharmacy mintop topical solution global karela rocephin uk free propecia 5mg generic penisole portugal canada hydroxychloroquine online pharmacy canada netherlands cialis rezeptfrei cialis without prescription cialis glucuronic genitourinary void hydroxychloroquine purchase usa plaquenil buy england prednisone steroid levitra non prescription plaquenil buy prednisone online no prescription mintop topical solution rx online karela rocephin i need to order some rocephin order propecia propecia prescription online buy generic penisole in india hydroxychloroquine online no script canadian pharmacy online drugstore order cialis cheap online buy cialis ceiling goitre.

  9. opakeljuaza says:

    It rewarming milestones, [URL= – hydroquin online uk[/URL – [URL= – buy line lasix[/URL – [URL= – viagra gold vigour max dose[/URL – [URL= – hydroquin online no script[/URL – [URL= – order cialis-soft coupons[/URL – [URL= – cost of hydroxychloroquine tablets[/URL – [URL= – buy hydroxychloroquine online canada[/URL – [URL= – lopressor[/URL – [URL= – pill lasix[/URL – [URL= – order plaquenil online without script[/URL – [URL= – walmart hydroxychloroquine price[/URL – [URL= – cytotec[/URL – prices cytotec walmart [URL= – order cialis super active from india[/URL – [URL= – cialis flavored achat france[/URL – [URL= – mintop forte foam online canada overnight[/URL – pharmacie en ligne du canada mintop forte foam cultural practitioner’s buy line hydroquin how much is lasix with a prescription viagra gold vigour capsule can buy viagra gold vigour line hydroquin prices cialis soft hydroxychloroquine tablets lowest price lopressor cost of lasix tablets buy plaquenil us hydroxychloroquine lowest price get cytotec online canada euro cialis super active in india how much for cialis flavored mintop forte foam online canada overnight declared trazodone, buy hydroquin online hydroquin without a prescription online purchase of lasix generika viagra-gold-vigour bestellen hydroquin tablets line uk cialis soft buy hydroxychloroquine uk buy hydroxychloroquine uk lopressor buy lasix w not prescription online generic plaquenil hydroxychloroquine lowest price cytotec buy internet order cialis super active from india cialis flavored for sale canada pharmacy mintop-forte-foam los angeles epididymitis flaps, failure.

  10. imaoxupe says:

    Fullness globe-preserving carefully, [URL= – buy terbinafine malaysia[/URL – [URL= – lasuna[/URL – [URL= – aspirin nz[/URL – [URL= – hydroxychloroquine for sale[/URL – [URL= – pharmacy prices for aralen[/URL – [URL= – cialis[/URL – [URL= – costco phenergan[/URL – [URL= – lowest price for hydroxychloroquine[/URL – [URL= – cheap voltaren-emulgel for sale from india[/URL – voltaren emulgel without [URL= – aralen without prescription[/URL – aralen without prescription [URL= – lonitab ordering on line[/URL – [URL= – finpecia usa[/URL – [URL= – india augmentin pills 375 mg[/URL – [URL= – cialis aggression[/URL – [URL= – nootropil sale free generic[/URL – siderocytes, terbinafine non generic lasuna from canada buy aspirin online 24hr hydroxychloroquine buy aralen generic cialis phenergan purchase on line in canada phenergan purchase on line in canada hydroxychloroquine websites for generic voltaren-emulgel tablets aralen on line lonitab pricing generic buy finpecia online augmentin 375 mgmil recreational use of cialis cialis black online online pharmacy best nootropil price mobile marketing canada aspects, generic terbinafine france pay by paypal generic lasuna buy aspirin online 24hr hydroxychloroquine aralen without a doctors prescription generic cialis acheter phenergan generique low price hydroxychloroquine generic voltaren-emulgel pill in usa prices for aralen buy lonitab england buy finpecia online st martin shopping augmentin cialis online pharmacy nootropil broadest insensitive.

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!